Sign inMy profileSign outJoin the CommunityFour critique moves—probe, surface, complicate, reframe—that preserve relationship while deepening thinking, plus a simple round structure and ground rules.
.webp)
Professional communities can become supportive without becoming educative. When everyone is careful, agreeable, or quick to affirm, important assumptions remain untouched.
This protocol provides four simple critique moves that preserve relationship while deepening thinking. The aim is a community that is both relationally supportive and intellectually demanding.
| Move | Purpose and possible language |
|---|---|
| Probe | Ask for the reasoning underneath the claim. What makes you think that? What evidence or experience is shaping that interpretation? |
| Surface | Name an assumption, value, or taken-for-granted idea. What assumption seems to be underneath this? What are we treating as obvious? |
| Complicate | Introduce another perspective, context, consequence, or tension. What might we be missing? Who might experience this differently? |
| Reframe | Offer a different way to define or interpret the issue. How else might this be understood? What changes if we frame the problem differently? |
The presenter owns the interpretation. Listeners choose one move each so the round deepens rather than piles on.
Which move do you use naturally? Which do you avoid? What would make your group's dialogue more rigorous without making it less trusting?