Sign inMy profileSign outJoin the CommunityThe many roles of a young teacher educator

As a math teacher, I like when things make sense. I like patterns, formulas, and knowing that if I follow the right steps, I can eventually arrive at an answer. Better yet, once I know the pathway, I can reproduce it as many times as I want. The numbers might change, but I still know which steps to take. Maybe once in a while I’ll approach the problem differently, just to see if it works. But no matter what, I can always fall back on what I know for sure, what has already been proven. Somewhere in my head, I think I assumed my professional life would work the same way. Teacher first. Then experience. Then a doctoral degree. Then, eventually, math teacher educator. Who would listen to me without all those pieces?
There was an order to it.
At least, I thought there was.
Then, at the beginning of my sixth year of teaching, I became an official mentor in my school district.
My first thought was some version of: Am I experienced enough to do this?
It was not that I had never supported another teacher before. I had. Over the years, I had answered questions, shared resources, talked through lessons, and informally helped newer teachers navigate some of the same things I had struggled with when I first entered the classroom. But “mentor” felt different. There was now a title attached to it. My district was formally trusting me to help another teacher learn and grow.
Six years earlier, I was the teacher who needed that person.
Now I was supposed to be that person.
The equation was no longer adding up the way I thought it would.
Becoming a mentor was not actually the first sign that my professional identity was shifting. It was simply one of the first times I stopped long enough to notice it.
When I began my doctoral program, I still thought of myself first as a classroom math teacher. Graduate school was something I was doing in addition to teaching. Research was something I was learning how to do. Teacher education was something I was studying.
As I became more familiar with teacher education research, I began thinking about what it actually meant to become a teacher educator. Butler et al. (2014) explored how doctoral students developed identities as future teacher educators through coursework, collaboration, and reflection. Their discussion of developing a teacher educator-researcher perspective particularly resonated with me. Yet somehow, I was still treating teacher education as something waiting for me in the future. I imagined that I needed to finish my doctorate, gain more experience, and eventually move into a university position before I could call myself a teacher educator. I had turned a process of becoming into another equation with steps I thought I needed to complete in order.
Slowly, those lines became less clear. I was no longer just studying teacher education. I was beginning to participate in it. I started researching how teachers learn, develop, and understand themselves. I worked on pieces that would eventually become publications and presented research at a conference for the first time.
Each experience added another variable. Math teacher + doctoral student + researcher + coauthor + presenter + mentor = ?
I am not sure when the answer started becoming a teacher educator.
Maybe that is because I was waiting for someone or something to tell me when I had earned that identity.
“Experienced enough” is an interesting standard because I am not sure what I thought enough would look like.
Ten years in the classroom?
A completed doctorate?
A university position?
A certain number of publications?
I had unconsciously created benchmarks for a role that, as I am learning, does not have a clear set of prerequisites.
Murray and Male (2005) found that even experienced classroom teachers faced challenges developing their identities when they moved into university-based teacher education. That made me think about how much importance I had placed on years of experience. If teachers with established careers were still figuring out what it meant to become teacher educators, why was I expecting myself to have everything figured out before I even began?
Becoming a district mentor disrupted that thinking. I could no longer place teacher education somewhere safely in my future. Someone else was now trusting me with part of their development as a teacher. This responsibility felt different from the informal support I had provided in the past. I thought about a teacher I had helped who was hired midway through the school year without a bachelor's degree. At the time, so much of my support was focused on helping them get through the immediate challenges of being in the classroom. Now, as an official mentor, I was beginning to think about something beyond simply surviving the school year. I wanted to help another teacher build the confidence, skills, and sense of belonging that would sustain them throughout their career.
At the same time, becoming a mentor did not suddenly make me feel finished developing as a teacher myself. I still change lessons. I still have days when something does not work. I still learn from colleagues. I still question my own decisions, and I am still learning from the decisions others make. I am simultaneously becoming more experienced and becoming aware of how much more there is to learn.
Maybe those two things are not contradictions.
Maybe they are part of becoming a teacher educator.
I used to imagine professional identities as somewhat sequential. You became one thing and then moved into the next.
My experience has been much more simultaneous.
I am a classroom math teacher and a doctoral student. I am learning to conduct research and beginning to contribute to it. I can present my work at a conference and still be in class the next week taking notes and asking questions. I can mentor another teacher and still need mentors of my own.
Butler et al. (2014) also emphasized collaboration and learning alongside others as important parts of developing a teacher educator identity. I can see that in my own experiences. I am still learning from professors, colleagues, and other teacher educators while beginning to support the development of teachers myself. Some days, I am the person asking questions, and other days, I am the person someone else comes to with theirs. I am realizing that these roles do not have to be separate.
And I think that simultaneity is what I had been missing when I tried to solve the equation.
Becoming a teacher educator has not required me to stop becoming a teacher.
Dinkelman et al. (2006) explored how beginning teacher educators carried their classroom teaching identities into their new roles. Although the teachers in their study had moved into university positions, I see a connection to my own experiences. I am not leaving my classroom behind as I begin developing this new identity. Instead, my experiences as a classroom teacher continue to shape how I support other teachers.
In fact, being close enough to my own early years of teaching to remember the uncertainty may be something I bring to mentoring rather than something that makes me less qualified to do it. I remember needing reassurance. I remember not knowing which questions I should even be asking. I remember what it felt like to watch experienced teachers make decisions almost automatically and wonder whether teaching would ever feel that natural to me.
Those memories are still close. Perhaps they should be.
I am still not completely comfortable saying, “I am a teacher educator.”
Maybe that is part of being early in this journey.
But I am beginning to recognize that becoming one did not start when my district officially called me a mentor. It did not start with my first conference presentation, my doctoral program, or a publication either.
There was no single variable that changed the answer.
Instead, these experiences have accumulated, overlapped, and changed how I see my responsibility to other teachers. Somewhere along the way, I stopped thinking about how I could become a better teacher and started thinking about how I could contribute to the learning and development of other teachers too.
That may be the shift I had been trying to calculate.
As a math teacher, part of me would still love a formula:
____ years of teaching + ____ experiences + ____ credentials = experienced enough.
I am starting to think those blanks are going to stay blank.
I wonder how many other teachers are already doing the work of teacher education without recognizing themselves as teacher educators. How many are mentoring colleagues, sharing what they have learned, or helping other teachers grow while still waiting for something to tell them they are experienced enough?
Maybe becoming a teacher educator is not an equation I am supposed to solve. Maybe it is something I will continue becoming; one role, one experience, and probably a few miscalculations at a time.
Butler, B. M., Burns, E. A., Frierman, C., Hawthorne, K., Innes, A., & Parrott, J. A. (2014). The impact of a pedagogy of teacher education seminar on educator and future teacher educator identities. Studying Teacher Education, 10(3), 255–274. https://doi.org/10.1080/17425964.2014.956716
Dinkelman, T., Margolis, J., & Sikkenga, K. (2006). From teacher to teacher educator: Experiences, expectations, and expatriation. Studying Teacher Education, 2(1), 5–23. https://doi.org/10.1080/17425960600557447
Murray, J., & Male, T. (2005). Becoming a teacher educator: Evidence from the field. Teaching and Teacher Education, 21(2), 125–142. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tate.2004.12.006
Share ideas, ask questions, and learn with colleagues around the world.
Browse more stories